New Delhi [India], November 19 (ANI): India should remove the 2010 prohibition on foreign direct investment (FDI) in tobacco manufacturing and review the industrial licensing restrictions in place since 1999, as the existing framework has limited market competition without demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing tobacco consumption, according to a report by India Foundation.
Dr Shamika Ravi, Member of the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM), released the report, 'The Anatomy of a Prohibition: Investment Law and the Reform of India's Tobacco Sector', by India Foundation's visiting fellow, Dr Raghav Pandey.
The October 2026 report recommended replacing the existing FDI prohibition with a conditional investment framework incorporating safeguards for tobacco growers, manufacturing capacity and public health.
"The report asks the Government to delete the entry that prohibits foreign direct investment in the manufacture of cigars, cheroots, cigarillos and cigarettes, of tobacco or of tobacco substitutes," the study stated.
It called for removing the prohibition under paragraph 5.1(g) of the Consolidated FDI Policy while simultaneously reviewing the government's longstanding practice of not issuing fresh industrial licences for cigarette manufacturing.
"The ask is the deletion of the FDI entry for tobacco manufacture paired with a reasoned review of the 1999 licensing practice beneath it," the report said. Pandey said that tobacco remains an integral cash crop within the Indian agrarian economy, yet the rules that shape the sector, from the farm to the factory, have never received a published assessment of what they achieve or what they cost.
According to the study, the FDI prohibition was introduced through Press Note No. 2 (2010 Series), issued on May 10, 2010, following a Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs decision in April 2010.
However, the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) had already stopped issuing fresh industrial licences for cigarette manufacturing on health grounds in 1999.
The report argued that removing the FDI prohibition without reviewing licensing restrictions would permit investment in existing manufacturing operations but would not necessarily introduce new manufacturers or additional buyers for tobacco farmers.
"A person newly free to invest is therefore not free to build," the study observed.
It further highlighted that while foreign investment in cigarette manufacturing remains prohibited, technology collaborations, licensing, franchise, trademark and management contracts continue to be permissible.
The report noted that entities belonging to the British American Tobacco group held 22.91 per cent of ITC as of June 30, 2026, while Philip Morris Global Brands held 25.10 per cent of Godfrey Phillips India.
"Hence the prohibition operates not as an exclusion of foreign money but as a freeze of the market as it stood in 2010, protecting incumbency from entry while leaving every non-equity channel open to those already seated," it stated.
Highlighting concerns over market concentration, the report argues that two restrictions froze the market instead of shrinking it: the 2010 ban on foreign direct investment (FDI) in cigarette manufacturing, and a 1999 freeze on new industrial licences that was never formally notified. The result is a duopoly, with two established companies buying 40 to 68 percent of the flue-cured Virginia (FCV) tobacco, the main cigarette leaf, sold at auction. Farmers are denied competitive bids, the report said, and are shut out of processing and manufacturing their own produce, an option open to growers of every other crop.
On consumption trends, the study cited a February 2026 working paper by the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister, which showed that the share of urban households reporting tobacco expenditure increased from 34.94 per cent in 2011-12 to 45.64 per cent in 2023-24.
Similarly, the share of rural households reporting tobacco expenditure rose from 59.31 per cent to 68.49 per cent during the same period.
The study also recommended replacing the Prohibition of Electronic Cigarettes Act, 2019, with a licensing and product standards framework, restricting novel nicotine products to verified adults aged 21 and above and establishing a Tobacco Transition Fund for cessation and cancer care.
It proposed mandatory nicotine and tar disclosures, stronger advertising restrictions and assessments of public health and competition effects before permitting changes in manufacturing capacity.
The report further recommended establishing a standing economic assessment mechanism to review tobacco-sector restrictions and ensure investment reforms are accompanied by stronger public health safeguards. (ANI)
India should lift FDI ban on tobacco manufacturing, review licensing restrictions, while ensuring safeguards for farmers, public health: India Foundation report